I doubt many would argue that MAC has some amazing presentation going on for Holiday this year. Gorgeous, but not exactly practical. My guess is it'll get dirty, quick.
Anyway, my hubby surprised me with the eye palette in Neutral Eyes. It contains 5 shadows; Blonde Mink, Magical Mist, Brun, Enviable, and Smut. Quality wise are these up to MACs permanent line? No, but I've never had an eye palette from them that is. The colors are very pretty, but they are a bit gritty and there is some fallout. Two colors, Brun and Smut, are part of the core collection. They are definitely better in that form.
Overall, it's a decent palette with nice neutral colors. Texture wise it's workable.