I picked this up recently since I had virtually no palettes in my stash. I wanted something neutral and this one caught my eye. It retails for $39, so less than the Naked palettes. I also had a 20% off any purchase at Ulta coupon, so this guy was a steal!
These are also my first Stila shadows. For the most part they feel nice and soft and have good pigmentation. Some of the darker shades are a bit sheer at a single pass, but it seem they can be built up. This also came with a great blackened brown eyeliner. swatches below are l-r, top row then bottom row.
Overall, I'm happy with it. It has a good selection of colors and matte and shimmery shades. I definitely think its worth checking out!